Antonia White, “Frost in May”

I was rather horrified when I first read this book, oh, a long time ago. So when Rachel of Book Snob and Carolyn of A Few of My Favourite Books proposed the delightful Virago Reading Week, Frost in May was the first title I thought of revisiting. I’m no longer horrified but I can see that Antonia White wanted me to be. What I can’t make out is where else the merit of this bitter little novel lies.

1980 U.S. edition

Fernanda Grey, age nine, is dropped off by her father at the Convent of the Five Wounds in the small village of Lippington. It is her first experience of boarding school, and her father is a new convert to Catholicism. Fernanda is being sent to the convent school to receive a Catholic education. Since Antonia White was herself educated at the Convent of the Sacred Heart in Roehampton, I suspect some of her anger stems from that experience. Certainly the fine-grained description of daily life at the school — the nuns’ handwriting, the descriptions of food, the pious fads, the way school routine erases home life — rings true. Fernanda is an observant, intelligent, imaginative little girl who grows into an observant adolescent who likes to write. Stand-in for the author? Seems likely, doesn’t it?

Since the entire book is narrated from Nanda’s point of view it’s a good thing she’s observant. She uses the sharp gaze of an outsider, for not only is she a convert, she is also middle-class. But “Lippington,” as the school is known, is the favored educational venue for a kind of borderless European aristocracy. The glamorous girls are Spanish, Irish, Franco-German, and feature cardinals and abbesses on their family trees. Nanda, though accepted as a friend, can never share their easy identification as members of the one True Church.

But as we might guess from the title, this is an education gone awry. White is sharp about the power the nuns exert over their charges, the surveillance and what we might call emotional blackmail. The founding principle of the school is the breaking of a child’s character so that it may be re-formed in a manner more pleasing to God. This is the “frost” of the title, of course.

But is there more to the tale than the humiliation and grief visited upon a young girl?  Nanda is well-drawn, but the secondary characters — those glamorous aristocratic Catholic girls — tend to be endowed with marvelous heads of hair and a few tics. The nuns are stock figures as well, remote and manipulative. (Rumer Godden does a much better job of seeing beyond the habit.) White’s hurt and outrage are fresh, but they are the only note she sounds.

Here’s a link to a Guardian piece from 2008 which informed me that Frost in May was the first volume Virago published. The author, Eloise Millar, reveals how closely autobiographical the novel is — promise I didn’t know!

This is my first entry in the Virago Modern Classics Reading Week challenge. Next up, Elizabeth Taylor’s Palladian. I’m afraid it looks a little cheerless, too!


About carolwallace

I spend most of my time writing and reading. Most recent publications: the reissue of "To Marry an English Lord,"one of the inspirations for "Downton Abbey," and the historical novel "Leaving Van Gogh." I am too cranky to belong to a book group but I love the book-blogging community.
This entry was posted in classic and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Antonia White, “Frost in May”

  1. bookssnob says:

    I seem to be the only person who really enjoyed this and didn’t find it depressing and upsetting. I read it a couple of years ago, shortly after I started blogging, actually, and I really loved it. I think Antonia White portrays the closeted life of school brilliantly and the following books are very good as well. I hope you enjoy Palladian a bit more!

  2. cousinsread says:

    I’m also reading a Virago set in a Catholic girls’ school – The Land of Spices by Kate O’Brien. The nuns in mine are sympathetic and so are the girls. I’m finding O’Brien to be really good at creating complex characters. Enjoy the rest of Virago Week!

  3. carolwallace says:

    I’m really glad you mentioned this and I’ll look forward to your review; as you can imagine, you are not the first person who has suggested Kate O’Brien to me!

  4. Pingback: Virago Reading Week: Round Up #1 « A Few of my Favourite Books

  5. I’ve just finished reading Frost in May, for the first time. I’d heard so much about it – I did like it – and oh yes ‘those ‘glamorous aristocratic catholic girls’! Having just read The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie it fitted in well with my thoughts and I realised how I kept thiking about the two novels. I think I’ve had my school girl literature fix for the winter and spring now.

    • carolwallace says:

      Maybe the Muriel Spark would be a good followup — it’s been a long time since I read that, too. Thanks, Joan!

  6. Annie says:

    ‘Frost in May’ was my first ever Virago, Carol and I went on to read the other three in the series straight afterwards. I’ve never been back to them, but I’ve often thought about it and I can see them sitting on my bookshelf as I write. Now I’m not sure if I should. Have you read the other three? If so, what did you think of those?

    • carolwallace says:

      I haven’t and I’m not terribly tempted — there was something so needy about “Frost in May” that more of Antonia White doesn’t appeal. She had such comprehensive access to a teenage hurt, and I prefer fiction that does more to transform experience. A quirk.

  7. Pingback: Virago Reading Week » Novel Readings - Notes on Literature and Criticism

  8. Pingback: Are You a Virago? « Book Group of One

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s